school of fish in background
Skip to page Header home about your sanctuary visiting your sanctuary education science management news and events protecting resources image library document library opportunities volunteers advisory council partners NOAA logo - a circle with a stylized seabird in flight; background is dark blue above the bird and light blue below the bird.

blank spaceFind us on Facebook

     Follow @fgbnms on Twitter

     


Science
Skip to Main Content
Science Home    Research    Monitoring    Habitat Characterization
Research Projects    Expeditions    Tools & Technology
Research Publications/Chronology

EAST AND WEST BANK MONITORING

Long-term monitoring efforts at East and West Flower Garden Banks take place in 100 meter square study sites (one at each bank). The study sites are marked out with 100-meter measuring tapes and colored string.

A diver holding on to a large metal stake at the midpoint of one side of a study site.  A measuring tape runs past this stake to the corners of the site.
Metal stakes embedded in the reef mark the corners and midpoints of each side of the study areas.
(Image: FGBNMS/Park)

A metal eye-bolt embedded in the reef with one green string and one red string creating quadrants. One string lies east/west and the other lies north/south.
A pin at the center of the study site allows researchers to divide the site into quadrants, which makes it easier to navigate around the site and locate photo stations.
(Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl)

All of the monitoring activites take place within the study site.

Random Transects

Seventeen non-overlapping images are taken along 10-meter transects placed randomly about the reef. These images are later evaluated for benthic cover percentages of coral, algae, sponge and substrate.

Diver photographing a monitoring station on the reef. Transect lines run across the reef on either side of the diver.
Taking photos along a random transect.
(Image: FGBNMS/Hickerson)

Repetitive Photo Stations

Metal pins placed at various locations around the reef mark stations where comparative photos are taken year after year. Over the years, some stations have gone missing and some new stations have been established, but many of the original stations are still used. Newer pins have been installed, as needed.

A metal eye-bolt with a plastic yellow ID tag that says W25, indicating West Flower Garden Bank station 25
Pin marking a repetitive photo station.
(Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl)

Repetitive photo stations images are taken using a camera mounted on a t-frame. The base of the frame is placed at the pin and oriented so the compass on top is facing north. A level on top of the t-frame helps the photographer get the same angle on the photo from year to year.

Looking over the shoulder of a diver taking a monitoring photo of the reef.
Taking a repetitive photostation image.
(Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl)

Taking the same image in the same way, year after year, provides a time series of specific coral colonies. Click here to see examples of time series from 1989-2014 at East Flower Garden Bank and West Flower Garden Bank.

These images are evaluated for benthic cover percentages of coral, algae, sponge and substrate using a Coral Point Count program.

Screen capture of a repetitive photo station image being analyzed in the Coral Point Count program. The specific species of benthic organism under each randomly generated red + mark is identified.
A Coral Point Count program is used to to identify benthic cover down to the species leve at 100 random data points, for each image.

Repetitive Lateral Stations

Repetitive lateral growth stations are located near the edges of Pseudodiploria strigosa colonies (brain coral) to capture images of the growing edges.

Metal plate bolted to reef, near a brain coral, with a number tag L604 attached.
Keyhole template used to line up the camera for images at a lateral growth station. (Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl)

The metal plate marking each station is designed with keyhole notches that the camera frame will fit into to guarantee the correct photo orientation is achieved each year.

Diver positioning a camera pole in a metal keyhole template bolted to the reef near a brain coral colony
Taking a lateral growth station photo to see how much
a brain coral colony has grown from year to year.

(Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl)

Images from the lateral stations is evaluated for growth, retreat or stasis of the brain coral colonies that are photographed.

Fish Surveys

Bohnsack surveys are conducted to quantify the number, species and size of fish at random locations on the reef.

To conduct these surveys, a diver will first float above a specific point on the reef and gradually rotate for 5 minutes, noting all of the species seen within a 15 meter cylinder of that point.

The diver will next spend one minute rotating in place observing the number and sizes of each species on the original list. If 10 species are listed, the diver does ten 1-minute surveys, each for a different species.

Diver swimming over the reef with a clipboard in hand
Conducting a fish survey above a transect line.
(Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl)

Lobster & Urchin Surveys

About 1.5 hours after sunset, divers conduct lobster and sea urchin surveys along the perimter lines of the study site. They note the number of spiny lobsters, slipper lobsters and long-spined urchins that they see.

A long-spined urchin poking out from under the edge of a brain coral with a spone and algae near by.
Urchin and lobster counts are conducted along random transects at night. (Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl)

Click here to learn more about the 2010 East/West Monitoring Expedition.

For more information on the use of repetitive photo stations in our monitoring efforts, please visit our Stetson Monitoring page.

top of page

MONITORING HISTORY

The earliest quantitative data on coral and other invertebrate cover at the Flower Garden Banks was collected in 1972 in 27 quadrants, each measuring approximately 12 square meters (Bright and Pequegnat, 1974).

The first regularly collected data on benthic communities occurred in 1978 (Viada, 1980) and continued through 1983 (CSA, 1985). This work was prompted by the drilling activities of Mobil Exploration and Producing U.S., Inc., within 1.7 km of the coral reefs at East Flower Garden Bank.

Minerals Management Service (MMS), now known as Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM), required that industry sponsor the monitoring program as well as pre- and post-drilling surveys to evaluate the fate and effects of their discharges on the sensitive biological assemblages inhabiting the nearby banks. This involved chemical analysis of sediments taken from the vicinity of the platforms but did not involve biological collections from either of the banks.

Following the completion of the study by CSA in 1983, no new activity was proposed so no further benthic monitoring was conducted at the Flower Garden Banks for nearly 6 years.

In consultation with academia and industry, MMS developed a comprehensive benthic monitoring program for the Flower Garden Banks in the late 1980's. This Long-Term Monitoring program remained in place, with some modifications, from 1988 through 2008.

With the arrival of R/V Manta, a state-of-the-art research vessel, in 2008, it was decided that the sanctuary now had the capabilities to take on the Long-Term Monitoring program itself. In August 2009, the sanctuary completed its first data collection efforts at East and West Flower Garden Banks.

MONITORING LESSON

We have also developed an educational lesson using actual photos from East and West Flower Garden Banks monitoring efforts.

Front page of Stetson Monitoring lessonDownload Reef Monitoring Lesson (636kb pdf)

East Flower Garden Bank Images for pin 101 and West Flower Garden Bank Images for pin 501 are available for use with this lesson.

See what other lessons are available by visiting the Education page of our Document Library.

top of page

LONG-TERM MONITORING REPORTS

A complete listing of the most recent long-term monitoring reports for East and West Flower Garden Banks can be found below.

2015

Long-Term Monitoring at East and West Flower Garden Banks: 2014 Annual Report (4MB pdf)

2014 Long-Term Monitoring at East and West Flower Garden Banks summary (274kb pdf)

Long-Term Monitoring at East and West Flower Garden Banks: 2013 Annual Report (3MB pdf)

2013 Long-Term Monitoring at East and West Flower Garden Banks summary (1.7MB pdf)

Long-Term Monitoring at East and West Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary, 2011-2012. Volume 1: Technical Report - Summary of results from long-term monitoring data collected in 2011 and 2012 (205 pages, 8.9MB pdf). BOEM 2015-027

Long-Term Monitoring at East and West Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary, 2011-2012. Volume 2: Appendixes - Appendixes for the 2011-2012 long-term monitoring report (409 pages, 10MB pdf). BOEM 2015-028

2013

2013-014 Long-Term Monitoring at the East and West Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary, 2009–2010; Volume 1: Technical Report (5MB pdf)

2013-015 Long-Term Monitoring at the East and West Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary, 2009–2010; Volume2: Appendices (10MB pdf)

2010

2010-052 Long-Term Monitoring at the East and West Flower Garden Banks: 2004-2008 - Volume I: Technical Report
2010-053 Long-Term Monitoring at the East and West Flower Garden Banks: 2004-2008 - Volume II: Appendices

2008

MMS 2008-027 Long-Term Monitoring at the East and West Flower Garden Banks 2004-2005 -- Interim Report - Volume I: Technical Report
MMS 2008-028 Long-Term Monitoring at the East and West Flower Garden Banks 2004-2005 -- Interim Report - Volume II: Appendices
2006 MMS 2006-035 Long-Term Monitoring at the East and West Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary, 2002-2003

top of page

2003

MMS 2003-031 Long-term Monitoring of the East and West Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary, 2000-2001

2001

MMS 2001-101 Long-term Monitoring at the East and West Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary 1998-1999

1999

MMS 99-0005 Long-Term Monitoring of the East and West Flower Garden Banks, 1996-1997

1996

MMS 96-0046 Long-Term Monitoring at the East and West Flower Garden Banks

For older reports on the East and West Bank Long-Term Monitoring efforts, as well as many other interesting reports about the Gulf of Mexico region, you can visit the following Bureau of Offshore Energy Management (BOEM) website.

top of page




weather report observations cool stuff get wet


Orange, branching gorgonian (soft coral) anchored in a bed of sponges and other sea life.
   
National Marine Sanctuary logo - a stylized whale tail above waves