Scientists Investigate Mysterious Coral Mortality Event at East Flower Garden Bank

August 9, 2016

Several potential causes of the outbreak are under investigation, but it's most likely a combination of stressors at work.

Video of mass mortality event. . HD Version

0:00 - The brown coral on the left is healthy star coral. The two faded colors on the same coral (below center) are dying or dead coral, and you can see the tissue sloughing off. We don't know whether the white mat caused the stress that killed the coral polyps. In this picture, it would appear not, unless a noxious chemical like hydrogen sulfide is coming from the mat or the sponge beneath it. Some think that there may be a mass mortality of sponges associated with this event. If the sponges are now rotting away, forming hydrogen sulfide, that could promote the growth of the bacteria that may be forming that mat (it could be a genus called Beggiatoa, a sulfide oxidizing bacteria), but we are still investigating this idea.

0:21 - A dead brittle star lying among filamentous algae on the reef.

0:28 - A white mat that could be bacteria growing over a sponge and peeling off in places.

0:41 - A white mat that could be bacteria growing over another sponge and peeling off in places.

0:55 - Though the lower portion of this massive star coral appears to be bleached from a distance, it has actually lost its tissue. The camera is looking down into a sand-filled depression on the reef.

1:02 - A brain coral that has lost tissue next to a healthy star coral.

1:05 - This is an area with a high number of brain and star coral colonies that have lost tissue.

Although the reefs of Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary (FGBNMS) are normally considered the healthiest in the region, on July 25, sport divers on the M/V FLING, reported green, hazy water, huge patches of ugly white mats on corals and sponges, and dead animals littering the bottom at East Flower Garden Bank, buoy #4.

360 degree video at a survey site at East Flower Banks buoy #4 showing approximately 20% mortality of the coral cover. Credit: FGBNMS/Johnston. HD Version

The charter captain immediately notified FGBNMS and BOEM (Bureau of Ocean Energy Management) researchers, who were just a few hundred yards away, conducting long-term monitoring efforts at buoy #2. The FGBNMS team responded quickly to the reports and was able to conduct several benthic and fish surveys, and collect some samples in the area before heading back to shore.

Map of the coral reef cap at East Flower Garden Bank as of 8/7/16 with numbers showing mooring buoy locations. Colors from blue to yellow to red indicate 0-70% mortality of coral around these buoy areas, resulting from a mysterious mass mortality event
A map showing coral mortality at East Flower Garden Bank around numbered buoy locations as of 8/7/16. Impacts range from 0% mortality near buoys #1 and #2 to 70% mortality between buoys #4 and #7.

Several potential causes of the outbreak are under investigation, but it's most likely a combination of stressors at work. Scientists from around the world are offering advice and assistance in trying to help discover the cause.

Bathymetric map of the reef cap of East Flower Garden Bank with numbers 1-7 showing buoy locations.
Corals affected by the mortality event at East Flower Garden Bank. Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl

An initial response cruise was launched with Texas A&M University (TAMU), July 30-August 2, to collect water samples for water chemistry sampling.

FGB-RR16 Cruise Report (pdf 4.8MB)

A second response cruise, led by FGBNMS, with partners from Rice University, UNCW-Chapel Hill and TAMU, took place August 4-7. Researchers conducted photo transects and scooter surveys, and collected over 300 samples of corals and sponges, both affected and unaffected, as well as directed water samples in specific areas of the impacted reef. These samples will be analyzed to look at the micro-organism communities and also genetic markers that may indicate specific types of stress. TAMU also deployed a glider that will be running transects throughout the area to continue characterization of the water column.

Two divers kneeling in a sand patch taking samples from nearby corals.
FGBNMS diver Marissa Nuttall and coral researcher Dr. Sarah Davies (UNC) sampling corals affected by the mortality event, under a sanctuary permit. Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl

Based on surveys so far, about 6.3% of the corals located in the shallower (< 90 feet) portions of the reef cap on East Flower Garden Bank were affected by the mortality event. These affected corals are spread across 6.5 acres, with some locations exhibiting up to 70% mortality. This could mean several thousand dead coral colonies and untold numbers of associated reef invertebrates including sponges, brittle stars, sea urchins, crabs, worms and shrimp. Many of the dead coral colonies are tens of hundreds of years old.

Close view of a section of reef where about 50-70% of the coral is white instead of its normal color
Corals affected by the mortality event at East Flower Garden Bank. Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl

Although it is still unclear what caused the coral and organism mortality, researchers think the event may no longer be active, except for some discrete areas.

A very large colony of star coral with about 2 feet of its bottom edges turned pale or white.
The effects of the mortality event seem to be from the bottom upwards, as seen in this large star coral colony. Image: FGBNMS/Schmahl

Sanctuary scientists will continue monitoring the area to document recovery over time. Observations will take place more frequently in the short term, followed by annual surveys. Scientists will also be on the look-out for possible indications of additional mortality or coral disease.

Meanwhile, sanctuary managers continue to request that divers and fishers avoid the impacted areas to allow the reef time to heal and to limit the possibility of transferring whatever caused the die-off to healthy areas.

Initial Report, July 2016

Investigation Continues, September 2016

For more information, contact Emma.Hickerson@noaa.gov or Steve.Gittings@noaa.gov